Add catamorphism generator (#97)

This commit is contained in:
Patrick Stevens
2024-02-17 23:16:54 +00:00
committed by GitHub
parent f55a810608
commit 3ea1c7ab79
21 changed files with 2259 additions and 16 deletions

View File

@@ -23,6 +23,7 @@ Currently implemented:
* `RemoveOptions` (to strip `option` modifiers from a type).
* `HttpClient` (to stamp out a [RestEase](https://github.com/canton7/RestEase)-style HTTP client).
* `GenerateMock` (to stamp out a record type corresponding to an interface).
* `CreateCatamorphism` (to stamp out a non-stack-overflowing [catamorphism](https://fsharpforfunandprofit.com/posts/recursive-types-and-folds/) for a discriminated union).
## `JsonParse`
@@ -326,6 +327,78 @@ thereby allowing the programmer to use F#'s record-update syntax.
* You may supply an `isInternal : bool` argument to the attribute. By default, we make the resulting record type at most internal (never public), since this is intended only to be used in tests; but you can instead make it public with `[<GenerateMock false>]`.
## `CreateCatamorphism`
Takes a collection of mutually recursive discriminated unions:
```fsharp
[<CreateCatamorphism>]
type Expr =
| Const of Const
| Pair of Expr * Expr * PairOpKind
| Sequential of Expr list
| Builder of Expr * ExprBuilder
and ExprBuilder =
| Child of ExprBuilder
| Parent of Expr
```
and stamps out a type like this:
```fsharp
type ExprCata<'Expr, 'ExprBuilder> =
abstract Const : Const -> 'Expr
abstract Pair : 'Expr -> 'Expr -> PairOpKind -> 'Expr
abstract Sequential : 'Expr list -> 'Expr
abstract Builder : 'Expr -> 'ExprBuilder -> 'Expr
type ExprBuilderCata<'Expr, 'ExprBuilder> =
abstract Child : 'ExprBuilder -> 'ExprBuilder
abstract Parent : 'Expr -> 'ExprBuilder
type Cata<'Expr, 'ExprBuilder> =
{
Expr : ExprCata<'Expr, 'ExprBuilder>
ExprBuilder : ExprBuilderCata<'Expr, 'ExprBuilder>
}
[<RequireQualifiedAccess>]
module ExprCata =
let runExpr (cata : Cata<'ExprRet, 'ExprBuilderRet>) (x : Expr) : 'ExprRet =
failwith "this is implemented"
let runExprBuilder (cata : Cata<'ExprRet, 'ExprBuilderRet>) (x : ExprBuilder) : 'ExprBuilderRet =
failwith "this is implemented"
```
### What's the point?
Recursing over a tree is not easy to get right, especially if you want to avoid stack overflows.
Instead of writing the recursion many times, it's better to do it once,
and then each time you only plug in what you want to do.
### Features
* Mutually recursive DUs are supported (as in the example above).
Every DU in a recursive `type Foo... and Bar...` knot will be given an appropriate cata, as long as any one of those DUs has the `[<CreateCatamorphism>]` attribute.
* There is *limited* support for records and for lists.
### Limitations
**I am not at all convinced of the correctness of this generator**, and I know it is very incomplete (in the sense that there are many possible DUs you could write for which the generator will bail out).
I *strongly* recommend implementing the identity catamorphism for your type and using property-based tests ([as I do](./WoofWare.Myriad.Plugins.Test/TestCataGenerator/TestDirectory.fs)) to assert that the correct thing happens.
Feel free to raise GitHub issues with code I can copy-paste to reproduce a case where the wrong thing happens (though I can't promise to look at them).
* This is a particularly half-baked generator which has so far seen no real-world use.
It likely has a bunch of [80/20](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pareto_principle) low-hanging fruit remaining, but it also likely has impossible problems to solve which I don't know about yet.
* Only a very few kinds of DU field are currently implemented.
For example, this generator can't see through an interface (e.g. the kind of interface one would use to implement the [crate pattern](https://www.patrickstevens.co.uk/posts/2021-10-19-crates/) to represent a [GADT](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Generalized_algebraic_data_type)),
so the generated cata will simply grant you access to the interface (rather than attempting to descend into it to discover recursive references).
You can't nest lists deeply. All sorts of other cases are unaddressed.
* This generator does not try to solve the "exponential diamond dependency" problem.
If you have a case of the form `type Expr = | Branch of Expr * Expr`, the cata will walk into both `Expr`s separately.
If the `Expr`s happen to be equal, the cata will nevertheless traverse them individually (that is, it will traverse the same `Expr` twice).
Your type may represent a [DAG](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Directed_acyclic_graph), but we will always effectively expand it into a tree of paths and operate on each of the exponentially-many paths.
# Detailed examples
See the tests.